Mary sings as she helps Jack decorate his house for the big Christmas party. Jack trims the tree, and talks about the famous guests he invited. Also about Barbara, the girl that Jack alegedly stole away from Phil a few episodes earlier. Rochester greets the gang as they arrive. Kenny sings, O Little Town of Bethlehem.
As Jack continues trimming the tree, Mary reads rejection telegrams from each of his celebrity guests. Despite a few mishaps, Jack remains in the Christmas spirit. Andy Devine arrives to play Santa Claus for the gang. Phil plays some mood music, then Jack gets a surprise when Phil brings Joan Bennet for his date.
Joan gets to joke around about the film she just made with Jack.