Back at the ranch, Mary shares her message that was on her silver arrow. Clark wants to head after the shadowy figure outside alone, but Tumbleweed insists on helping him.
Meanwhile, Jimmy talks to Mary to learn how she came to be in the ghost town, looking for the Silver Arrow. Mary is a school teacher, and shares about her ancestor, a real Western badman. How does he play into the story Clark and Jimmy learned earlier about the legendary character, The Silver Arrow?
Suddenly, the candle has burned low, and a figure has snuck into the room. Jimmy and Mary have been attacked, but they’re OK, and they talk about the man with long white whiskers. Clark proves it couldn’t be Hopeful Jake, the man who first told them of the Silver Arrow. Should Clark and Tumbleweed play rough with the old timer to learn more details to the story?