Andy Hill had been living a life, reformed from his past outlaw days. He has made a positive impression on everybody in town including Matt and Kitty. When a report comes in that Andy is wanted to be returned to stand trial in Oklahoma, Matt plans to ignore it.
When the deputy from out of state arrives, Matt learns that Andy’s charges are heavier than he knew about. What’s Matt going to do now? Is Andy the liar the deputy claims he is? Andy claims to be innocent of murder, and the deputy may have reason to get revenge on him.
Matt finds a clue that exposes some truth behind the visiting deputy, but it won’t be resolved without gunplay.